Discussions about the concept of declaring a climate emergency

Australian political issues in search on 9 May 2019: Climate change ranks as the Number One issue out of 22 election topics. Updated version

Discussion in Hobart Council








 

→ ABC News – 21 May 2019:
Hobart Council row erupts as members stage a meeting walkout against climate change motion
“A row has erupted inside the walls of Hobart City Council over a motion to recognise climate change as a global emergency.”

 

 


Suggestions and considerations


“Tectonic plates finally shifting”

“What a few weeks it’s been in terms of the sense of urgency and proportion in relation to climate change and the world’s unravelling ecological crisis. Extinction Rebellion, Greta Thunberg, David Attenborough, the Welsh and Scottish governments declaring a climate emergency, then the UK and Irish parliaments. There appears to be a new, and long-overdue, sense of ambition and momentum, of tectonic plates finally shifting deep below the surface.”
~ Rob Hopkins, co-founder of the Transition Town movement

→ Resilience.org – 15 May 2019:
Why the Climate Emergency needs a National Imagination Act
Article by Rob Hopkins

 


 


Vancouver’s Climate Emergency Will Change the Way You Live

“In January, Vancouver became the second major Canadian city (Montreal was first) to declare the potential effects of future climate change “an emergency” for our city. The alternative: more forest fires and floods. Councillor Christine Boyle‘s resolution passed unanimously.

In response, city staff proposed ‘6 Big Moves’ to be implemented within the next six to 11 years.

How will that change the way you live? We’ll easily walk or bike to get most of our daily needs. We’ll use much more public transit, and most private vehicles will be electric. Buildings and water will be heated by solar, wind, and hydro power. New buildings will be 40% more energy efficient. And we’ll restore forests and coastal ecosystems that capture carbon.

To guide us through these changes, we welcome Councillor Christine Boyle; Atiya Jaffar, digital campaigner for 350.org; and New Westminster Councillor Nadine Nakagawa.”


 

→ Huffington Post – 22 May 2019:
Parliament Declared A Climate Emergency – Now It Must Ditch Fossil Fuels
“Public concern about our planetary crisis is hitting record highs – so why do a majority of over 400 sitting MPs not seem to take issue with their pensions being invested in fossil fuels?” – by Caroline Lucas, Green Party MP for Brighton Pavilion, UK

 

→ Gareth Kane on Linkedin.com – 4 June 2019:
“OK, you’ve called a climate emergency, now what?”
“The in-thing at the moment is to declare a climate emergency. The idea behind the ’emergency’ bit being that we need to act now, not later, to combat runaway climate impacts. So a huge number of organisations are declaring an emergency, and then… well… ummm… box ticked?”

 


Praise


“A new wave of climate awakening”

“This is one of the most a significant series of events for climate action in recent years with new declarations announced almost every day. And the momentum is fueling the beginning of a paradigm shift across broader society as thought leaders and commentators begin to call for super national action.

Sure, many big challenges remain for us to overcome, as there’s clearly a need to engage much deeper and more effectively with all Australians. But, let’s also use the momentum that is building and uphold the full scale and speed of action we need to achieve a safe and just transition.”
~ Luke Taylor, Director, Sustainable Living Foundation


“At the end of 2018, the dam finally burst and the Climate Emergency Movement has emerged, finally, as a powerful force. This movement tells the truth about the scale of the crisis, and demands a “Green New Deal” or a WWII-scale climate mobilization — a 10 year transition to zero emissions plus drawdown. Led by Alexandria Ocasio Cortez and the Justice Democrats in Congress, the Sunrise Movement, Zero Hour, School Strikers, and Extinction Rebellion in the streets, this movement has burst forth with tremendous force and momentum.”

→ Medium – 25 May 2019:
Leading the Public Into Emergency Mode
“Introducing the Climate Emergency Movement”

 

 


Criticism


“Top-down corporate and government solutions that entrench disadvantage and disenfranchisement”

“With the UK, Ireland and Iceland all just declaring a climate emergency and a global movement swelling around the demand (including Peter Garrett calling on the ALP to declare one if they win government), it’s worth taking a step back, checking our privilege and seeing that emergency powers being invoked rarely fairs well for people of colour or those on the margins of our society.

Initially my trepidation was a communications response – you can’t compel people to take sustained action by instilling fear – they need anger (at the fossil fuel industry), solidarity or hope to act. But when you dig a little deeper, this call for an “emergency mobilisation of government resources” lends itself to top-down corporate and government solutions that entrench disadvantage and disenfranchisement, rather than putting decision-making in the power of people and creating a better world for everyone, not just a wealthy few.”
~ Kelly Albion, director of the Australian Youth Climate Coalition

→ AYCC – 15 May 2019:
Why calling for a “climate emergency” is not climate justice

 

 

“Kelly Albion from AYCC recently shared a blog post arguing why declaring a climate emergency is not climate justice. There are several reasons why I think this stance needs broader reflection and why I think that climate justice can and must be a part of climate emergency declarations and plans.”
~ Heidi Edmonds, Climate KISS

 

→ Climate KISS – 17 May 2019:
Why climate justice must be at the heart of the climate emergency declarations, not in opposition to them
By Heidi Edmonds


→ Vice – 30 May 2019:
Declaring a ‘Climate Emergency’ Is Meaningless Without Strong Policy
“A teen leading climate strikes in Canada says the Liberals’ motion is merely a ‘publicity stunt.’”



“Another layer of bureaucracy and red tape to a complex issue”

→ New Zealand National Party – 16 May 2019:
ECan climate change emergency not the answer
Press release: “Environment Canterbury’s decision to declare a climate change emergency will only add another layer of bureaucracy and red tape to a complex issue, National Local Government spokesperson Jacqui Dean says.”

 


“Wasteful spending”

New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union: “Louis and Porky the Waste-hater visit the Nelson City Council to turn up the heat on their $100,000 Climate Emergency Declaration.” 20 May 2019

 

 


Ezra Levant’s video monologue

 

 


Language


The Guardian adopts climate emergency language

→ The Guardian – 17 May 2019:
Why the Guardian is changing the language it uses about the environment
Instead of “climate change”, the preferred terms are “climate emergency, crisis or breakdown”, and “global heating” is favoured over “global warming”, although the original terms are not banned.

 

→ The Conversation Canada – 7 June 2019:
Language matters when the Earth is in the midst of a climate crisis
“Can new language change the way the public and politicians perceive the hazards of the Earth’s changing climate?”

 

 


‘Climate Emergency Declaration’ versus ‘State of Emergency’

“Nuance of language is important. That’s how we ended up with the benign word “Climate Change” in the mainstream rather than “Global Warming” back in the 1990s.

Mexico currently has over 100 fires burning across the country. This article is talking about an understandable “State of Emergency” type of response to the immediate situation.

A “Climate Emergency Declaration” is different. It is a longer term regional strategy to the overall Climate Crisis even after these fires are put out, because we know that more extreme weather events and food security and social unrest are continuing our way.

If we don’t start changing our way of thinking, living, consuming and re-prioritising our needs and wants we are going to have Government and Corporations do it for us because that is what a State of Emergency is and that is a very different beast.”
~ Global Climate Emergency Now

 

 

→ Centre for Climate Safety – 6 June 2019:
600 climate emergency declarations: the beginning of a global referendum
“The declarations by 600 councils and local governments, plus a few state and national governments, can be seen as a slowly growing referendum on whether the people of this world believes we should do something serious about this emergency, or whether we should just continue to trust that the policies of our democratically elected leaders, next to do-nothing, are going to protect us sufficiently.”

 

 


Purpose


“Declaring an emergency means absolutely nothing unless there is action to back it up. That means the government having to do things they don’t want to do.”
~ Eamon Ryan, Green Party leader, Ireland

 


Emergency-level action to back the declaration up

“A climate change emergency fund will be created to get the ball rolling and cut global warming in Devon as rapidly as possible. Wednesday’s Devon County Council Cabinet meeting saw councillors unanimously agree to set aside £250,000 towards an initiative to persuade organisations, communities and individuals to do more to reduce global warming. And Chief Executives and Directors from nearly 20 public and private sector organisations in Devon have already given with one voice their unhindered commitment to tackling the climate emergency.”

 

→ Devon Live – 16 May 2019:
Devon agencies will act NOW to tackle climate emergency
“Public bodies, business representatives and utility companies – all members of a new Devon Climate Emergency Response Group – are supporting urgent action on the climate emergency.”

 

‘Crisis’ is throw your hands up. ‘Emergency’ is roll your sleeves up.”
~ Rachel Reese, Mayor, Nelson in New Zealand

 

 

Rationing energy?

→ Counterpunch – 31 May 2019:
WWII Lessons for the Climate Emergency
“A rational and responsible response to the intersecting climate and political disasters is the rationing of energy. There are historical precedents. Yet rationing, moratoriums, and a range of measures that could immediately cut emissions and address intersecting emergencies are largely ignored in climate policy.”
 

→ Resilience – 24 May 2019:
What would a Climate Emergency Plan Look Like?
“Across the world, national and local governments are declaring a climate emergency on the back of dire warnings from UN scientists about the need for urgent and far-reaching action that have triggered a wave of protests from school children and given rise to the Extinction Rebellion movement.”

 


“Surely what is required by the Earth that feeds us and so many other amazing creatures is a war-type, non-affiliated “cabinet”. It would include representatives from all sides of politics and be directed by non-politically aligned experts. (Any pecuniary interests would need to be declared.)

Structurally this could include an environmental wing of our armed forces (for example, the navy helping to clear plastics from our oceans and sewerage and chemical run-off which is destroying our Great Barrier Reef). It could provide school leavers with an interesting, voluntary, “national service” gap year of employment, and perhaps work and skills development for the unemployed.

Through the United Nations, we could suggest a co-operative approach between nations that could enhance eco-tourism and a sharing of innovative solutions.”
~ Steven Sommer, Highton

 

 



“This isn’t something we can wait for someone else to fix. We all need to act now. We can be leaders for change. Think globally, act locally.”
~ Ben Andrews – in a Facebook comment

 


Media coverage in May 2019

See examples of news stories and articles

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: